See All Mattresses

Plushbeds vs Amerisleep In Depth Comparison

From our experts

• Construction
• Durability
• Cooling
• Warrenty
• Back pain
• Sleep Type
• Dimension
• Conclusion

Construction

Plushbeds Mattresses9.4

Botanical Bliss

The Botanical Bliss comes in two levels of firmness: medium firm and medium. It’s also available in 9 inches, 10 inches and 12 inches. This mattress is made from 100% organic latex, with the inclusion of wool and cotton to the mix. The construction is in four layers for the 12 inches and 3 layers for both 9 and 10 inches.

Construction Details

Organic Cotton Cover

In the three varied inches of same mattress, an inch of organic cotton cover overlays the top layer. This cover is breathable, allowing for airflow to keep the sleeper cool all night.

9 inches Model

All three layers are made of organic 100% arpico latex and blended with up to 10 lbs of natural wool.

The first layer is 2 inches

The second and third are both 3 inches.

10 inches Model

Same 100% organic arpico latex makes the entire 3 layers. All 3 layers are 3 inches high and all blended with 10 lbs of natural wool.

12 inches Model

The 12 inches rose that high due to the addition of an extra layer making it four in total. The extra layer is 2 inches and sits at the top while the remaining 3 layers below it are all 3 inches high. Same natural latex and wool combination.

Luxury Bliss Latex

The Luxury Bliss is a hybrid mattress and is 12 inches high. Comes in two firmness: medium and medium-firm. Every layer is made from organic Dunlop Latex. It’s construction is in 2 layers.

Construction Details

Organic Cotton Cover and Wool

The entire mattress is wrapped in organic cotton cover which is sheer breathable and assures of a cool sleep. This cover is blended with organic Joma wool. The wool serves as the comfort layer alongside the cover. The wool is also a fire barrier.

Dunlop Latex

The first layer beneath the cover and comfort layer is occupied by 3 inches of Natural Dunlop Latex offering all the prime benefits of nature.

Pocketed Coils Support Core

Serving as the base is 8 inches of 15-16 pocketed coils for the resilient support, durability and over-all performance this mattress offers.

Natural Bliss Mattress

The Natural Bliss Mattress comes in 3 levels of thickness: 6 inches, 8 inches and 10 inches. It has four level of firmness: Soft, medium-firm, medium and firm. Each of the variant comes with different number of layers and is either made of Organic Dunlop Latex or Talalay Latex.

Construction Details

For the 6 inches Model ( one Layer)

Organic Cotton Cover

All three variants use same organic cotton cover for breathability and comfort.

Dunlop Latex Layer

This mattress is only one layer and that’s the 6 inches of Organic Dunlop Latex. It has no support core and no wool addition.

8 inches Model (2 layers)

Cover – remains the same

Comfort Layer

The comfort layer here is 2 inches of Talalay Latex. Talalay is more responsive and feels bouncy.

Support Core Layer

The second layer here which is also the support core is 6 inches of Organic Dunlop Latex for durability and structural stability.

10 inches Model ( 4 Layers )

Cover – remains the same

Comfort Layer

Two layers are in charge of comfort here. Both layers are 2 inches in height and are made of Talalay Latex.

Support Core

The support core is also in two layers, each is 3 inches high and are made of Organic Dunlop Latex.

Amerisleep Mattresses9.1

Top Cover

N/B: All mattresses from Amerisleep comes with the same cover and for the rest of this review, it will be needless dwelling on covers since there’s no difference. The cover for AS1 is same as that of AS2 to AS5, and the hybrid options equally.

The highlight of this cover on all mattresses from Amerisleep is the inclusion of Celliant which is blended with spandex and polyester.

The Celliant in the mix makes the cover cool to the touch and is also reputed to harbour therapeutic benefits for the muscle.

Comfort Layer

Surely made for comfort, this comfort layer is made up of a 2 inch Bio-pur® memory foam. This foam contours the body perfectly and allows you to sink in a little to relieve pressure points.

It’s also quite responsive since it’s just 2 inches, so you don’t get trapped while trying to get up. This layer also uses an open cell technology that makes it breathable to make the sleeper enjoy a cool sleep.

Base Layer

The core of this mattress is an 8 inch high-density polyfoam that offers all the support, resilience and durability for the few inched layers above it.

This layer is also responsible for the firmness of this mattress. On the basis of it’s sheer strenght, it was tagged the firmest mattress on the Amerisleep line.

AS2

The AS2 is also a firm mattress, but sits in the medium-firm range, making it ideal for stomach and back sleepers. Its construction is in three layers.

Construction Details

Cover – All covers are the same.

Top Layer

The first and top layer just beneath the cover is a 2 inch Bio-pur® memory foam that provides adequate contouring and pressure relief. It also keeps the body cool with an open cell technology. This top layer is very soft.

Middle Transition Layer

The second layer or middle layer consist of a 3 inch polyfoam. This layer is very firm and also known as the affinity layer.

Base Layer

Serving as base for the layers of this mattress is 7 inches of high-density polyfoam which is very firm and provides structural support for the mattress. There is also a zoned support system in place here which is a patented one to relieve pressure off pressure points, enhance alignment and reduce back pain.

AS3

AS3 is the most popular mattress on the Amerisleep mattress series. It sits at the middle in the firmness scale – not too soft and not too firm. So this mattress is recommended for side sleepers and those who change positions often. Its construction is in three layers.

Construction Details

Cover – The same with AS2 and AS1

Top Comfort Layer

3 inches of a Bio-pur® memory foam sits at the top layer for maximum coolness, softness and pressure relief.

Middle Transition Layer

2 inches of 1.65lb density  polyfoam serves as the second and transition layer. This layer transit the sleeper from the soft top layer to the medium firm base.

Base Support Layer

Serving as base and support for the entire mattress is 7 inches of high-density polyfoam which is average on firmness. It’s soft but provide the needed firmness for support.

AS4

The AS4 is on the soft side, specifically on the medium-soft range of the firmness scale making it ideal for side sleepers. It’s the second softest foam on the line. It’s construction is in 3 layers and it’s 12 inches in height.

Construction Details

Cover – Same Celliant cover.

Top Layer

The top layer consists of 4 inches of Bio-pur memory foam. This layer is typically soft, breathable and pressure-relieving.

Middle Transition Layer

An inch of breathable transition foam sits at the middle position to transit the sleeper from the soft surface to the firm support base layer using a surface modification technology. This layer also come with support zones to relief pressure from pressure points like the back, shoulders, neck and hips.

Base Support Layer

At the base is 7 inches of high-density Bio-core foam providing support to the entire mattress and enforcing durability.

 

AS5

AS5 is the softest mattress on the series and often known as the plush mattress. It’s the most sophisticated mattress on the Amerisleep series with four uniquely built layers and the signature Celliant cover. It’s also the highest in height at 14 inches.

Construction Details

Cover – same for all mattresses

Top Comfort Layer

The top layer of this mattress is 3 inches of Bio-pur® memory foam providing pressure relief in contouring and coolness in breathability.

Compression Layer

2 inches of foam known as the Active Flex layer sits just beneath the comfort layer. This layer is very soft but also come with the firmness of a memory foam. This layer is exclusive to the AS5 and also contributes to pressure relief by allowing you sink in not too deep to be trapped.

Transition Layer

This layer is 2 inches of foam that is well-spaced for a hitch-free air passage and subsequent cooling. It also serves as the bridge between the soft top layer and the firm support base layer. It is also zoned to guarantee pressure relief on pressure points.

Base Support Layer

At the foot of the layers is 7 inches of high-density polyfoam providing stability and durability to the layers above it.

The Hybrids (AS2, AS3 & AS5)

The construction of the hybrids for all three are basically same save for a few additions which include:

• Pocketed coils for extra breathability, comfort and durability
• Perimeter edge support system which makes getting in and out of the bed seamless

Durability

Plushbeds Mattresses9.4

All plushbeds mattresses are made to last. With materials derived from natural sources, they are designed for years of comfort and 25 years of assurance is already stamped.

Amerisleep Mattresses8.3

All mattresses from Amerisleep are created for durable comfort. They are all manufactured in the United States with the best quality materials available. Their durability is backed by a 20-year warranty.

Cooling and Comfort

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Since natural latex is involved in all the mattresses, coolness is assured. Organic latex sleeps cooler than memory foam and to further enhance this coolness, it features an open cell construction.

The ultra-mild organic cotton cover present in the mattresses gives room for uninterrupted air flow to keep things cool with the sleeper at the top and it’s softness offers cradle comfort.

In some of the variants where Talalay was used instead of Dunlop Latex, it’s even great news since Talalay is more responsive, soft and bouncy.

Amerisleep Mattresses8.8

Naturally, memory foam are infamous for inviting heat, but Amerisleep remedied that anomaly with the use of its Bio-pur® memory foam that features an open cell technology to keep heat at bay and keep the sleeper cool all night.

The Bio-pur® memory foam is breathable and wicks moisture away unlike conventional memory foams.

This same Bio-pur® is present in all mattresses including the hybrids versions.

Additionally, the soft nature of all of its first layers and the body contouring properties of same layers takes comfort to another realm.

Finally on comfort and coolness, the  signature Celliant cover of Amerisleep is another unique material that promotes a cool, comfortable and healthy sleep.

Back Pain Support

Plushbeds Mattresses9.5

The Botanical Bliss Mattress that makes use of 100% latex is being prescribed by orthopedics as a viable option for back pain therapy. The latex in this mattress contours the pressure points in your body and relief pressure ultimately off the back.

This same 100% natural Latex is also found in the Luxury Bliss and  Natural Bliss Mattresses, implying that they all provide the needed cradle support for back pressure relief as well as other pressure points in the body of a sleeper.

Amerisleep Mattresses8.8

The Bio-pur® memory foam in all mattresses, allows the body to sink into it while it contours it perfectly. In the process it relieves back pain by easing up pressure in pressure points.

There is also a targeted zone support transition layer present in all mattresses known as HIVE® which adds extra back support and relieves back pain ultimately. It enhances alignment on the spine and back, relieves back pain and cushions your back, shoulders and neck.

Trial and Warrenty

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Plushbeds offer a 100-night sleep trial on all mattresses. However, there’s a break-in period which lasts for 30-nights. Returning your mattress in the course of the first 30-nights attracts a $99 deduction from your refund. After the 100 nights, you can return the mattress if you don’t like it and get a refund.

For warranty, Plushbeds gives you a limited 25-year warranty. For the first 10 years, Plushbeds is going to replace your mattress or bear the cost of fixing it. Outside the first 10 years, repairs will be done at prorated costs.

Terms and conditions always apply.

Amerisleep Mattresses9.2

After purchase, you are given 100 nights risk-free trial and if you are still not comfortable with the mattress after that time window, you can return it and get a full refund.

All mattresses come with a limited 20-year warranty. For the first 10 years, Amerisleep will replace your mattress for any defect and that includes sagging above 0.75″. After the first 10 years, you will be receiving prorated replacements.

Sleeping Type

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Botanical Bliss

Since the Botanical Bliss comes in medium and medium-firm levels, it means that every sleeper can enjoy this mattress and more importantly, side and stomach sleepers are to going enjoy it better.

Luxury Bliss

Same firmness levels are present in the luxury mattress: medium and medium firm. Choose medium if you are chiefly a side sleeper and medium-firm if you are not loyal to any sleeping position all night.

Natural Bliss

The Natural Bliss packs almost all levels of firmness. Choose

Soft: If you are a side sleeper

Medium: if you are a side sleeper and back sleeper as well.

Medium-firm: if you change positions all night.

Extra-firm: if you are a back sleeper and a stomach sleeper.

Amerisleep Mattresses9.2

The highlight of Amerisleep comes in the distinction among sleeping types. Each mattress was designed to suit a particular sleeping type.

AS1

The AS1 was designed for back sleepers and to some extent, stomach sleepers. It’s the firmest mattress in the series.

AS2

AS2 was designed for stomach sleepers and partly for back sleepers. It’s on the medium-firm level.

AS3

AS3 is for side sleepers but since it sits at the middle in the firmness scale it can be used by all sleepers regardless of their sleeping positions.

AS4

AS4 is the second softest mattress and great for side sleepers. It’s on the medium-soft range.

AS5

AS5 is the softest mattress in the Amerisleep series. It’s on the soft side and great for side sleepers.

Dimensions

Conclusion

Amerisleep and Plushbeds are two brands that are in sharp contrast to each other in what they represent and the quality of their offerings.

While Plushbeds rely on nature for raw materials, Amerisleep goes with the conventional chemical route.

They share one thing in common however and that’s the variety in firmness levels.

Plushbeds has three mattreses while Amerisleep made all of its five mattresses in different firmness levels.

Comparatively, Plushbeds does better than Amerisleep despite its firmness highlights. Plushbeds paid more attention to comfort and support and has a longer warranty than Amerisleep at 25 years.